Skip to content

10 Best Gems for Engagement Rings That Aren’t Diamonds

While diamonds have reigned supreme for decades as the engagement ring stone of choice, a lot of couples in the United States are shirking tradition and seeking out a fun, colorful ring that reflects their personality. At Gemmere.com we know that the best engagement ring stone is gorgeous, hard-wearing, and meaningful. Here are 10 gorgeous gemstones that bring sophistication and allure to any engagement ring, a great alternative for a proposal you know will make a lasting impact.

 

Why Choose Non-Diamond Gems for Engagement Rings?

The Best gems for engagement rings offer a combination of uniqueness, value, and the chance to be a bit uncommon. Well, not only do those gemstones come with stronger, deeper hues, they also come with unique symbolism and often even better durability. Whether you prefer a splash of color or an ethically informed design, when it comes to non-diamond gems, the possibilities for a one-of-a-kind ring are endless.

 

Benefits of Choosing Alternative Gemstones

  • Uniqueness: Colored stones such as sapphires or emeralds differentiate your ring.
  • Affordability: Several gemstones are cheaper than diamonds.
  • Durability: Certain gems, such as sapphires, have high Mohs scores, guaranteeing durability.
  • Symbolism: Every gem has distinct meanings, ensuring personalization.

 

Top 10 Best Gems for Engagement Rings

The following are the top gems for engagement rings, each providing a special combination of elegance and practicality to American couples looking for something unique.

1. Sapphire Gemstone

Due to their deep blue shades, sapphires are one of the most gorgeous gems for engagement rings, and it comes as no wonder that sapphire’s hardness (Mohs 9) as well as the classic look can be matched to diamonds. Some species are pink, some are yellow, white and largely versatile, meaning loyalty and faithfulness. Since they're so tough, they're perfect for everyday wear.

2. Emerald Gemstone

Emerald is a green shade that brings a sophistication. Listed as a 7.5 - 8 on the Mohs scale, they’re a bit of a finicky stone but are perfect for those who love bold color. Both love and renewal are symbolized by emeralds, therefore giving a gift of an engagement ring which has an emerald is a romantic gesture.

3. Ruby Gemstone

Rubies, with their red-hot hue, are a beautiful diamond alternative. Ranking 9 on the Mohs scale, they're very resistant and symbolize love and protection. Rubies are perfect for couples looking for a dramatic, romantic expression.

4. Moissanite Gemstone

Moissanite is an affordable gem that closely approximates the sparkle of a diamond. With a Mohs rating of 9.25, it's also extremely durable and ethically sourced, making it one of the top gems for engagement rings for environmentally friendly couples.

5. Aquamarine Gemstone

Aquamarine's calm blue-green color inspires serenity and has a rating of 7.5–8 on the Mohs scale. This gem represents peace and bravery, ideal for couples who appreciate understated sophistication.

6. Morganite Gemstone

Morganite, soft pink or peach in color, is a beautiful romantic option for engagement rings. Being 7.5–8 on the Mohs scale, it's suitable for everyday wear and symbolizes love and compassion.

7. Amethyst Gemstone

Those who want affordability will find amethyst's rich purple color an interesting choice. Being 7 on the Mohs scale, it is not as durable but great for special occasions. Amethyst reflects clarity and calmness.

8. Topaz Gemstone

Blue topaz, for its bright but budget-friendly beauty, is an excellent option for engagement rings. At 8 on the Mohs scale, it's resistant and represents love and loyalty, one of the finest stones for engagement rings.

9. Garnet Gemstone

Garnets exist in several hues, with red being the favorite. With a Mohs of 6.5–7.5, they're durable enough for daily wear and represent commitment and passion.

10. Peridot Gemstone

Peridot’s bright green hue is unique and eye-catching. Rated 6.5–7 on the Mohs scale, it’s best for those who handle their rings with care. Peridot symbolizes strength and positivity.

 

How to Choose the Best Gems for Engagement Rings

Selecting the best gems for engagement rings involves balancing aesthetics, durability, and budget. Here are key factors to consider:

  • Durability: Gemstones with a Mohs rating of 7 or greater (e.g., ruby, sapphire, moissanite) are suitable for everyday wear.
  • Color Preference: Select a gem that suits your personality, ranging from bright emeralds to pale morganites.
  • Budget: Gems such as moissanite and amethyst are less expensive than diamonds or sapphires.
  • Ethical Sourcing: Select gems from good jewelers such as Gemmere.com, which are concerned about ethical practices.

 

How to Take Care of Your Non-Diamond Engagement Ring

To maintain your ring's sparkle, observe these care instructions:

  • Clean often using mild soap and water.
  • Store in a soft pouch to avoid scratching.
  • Avoid exposing softer stones (e.g., amethyst, peridot) to chemicals or trauma.

 

Why Shop at Gemmere.com?

Here at Gemmere.com, we are a leading source for the highest quality engagement ring gems online and for a great selection of the best fair trade gems on the market. Our professional ring builders assist in creating unique rings that portray your love story in power and grace.

 

FAQs About the Best Gems for Engagement Rings

What are the most durable gems for engagement rings?

Sapphires, rubies, and moissanite are among the most durable, with Mohs ratings of 9 or higher, making them ideal for daily wear.

Are non-diamond engagement rings more affordable?

Yes, gems like moissanite, amethyst, and topaz are often more budget-friendly than diamonds, offering stunning beauty at a lower cost.

Which gemstone is best for a unique engagement ring?

Sapphires and emeralds are excellent choices for unique rings due to their vibrant colors and versatility in design.

How do I care for my non-diamond engagement ring?

Clean your ring with mild soap and water, store it safely, and avoid harsh chemicals, especially for softer gems like amethyst or peridot.

Where can I find the best gems for engagement rings?

Visit Gemmere.com for a curated selection of high-quality, ethically sourced gemstones for custom engagement rings.

Cart

Your cart is currently empty.

Start Shopping

Select options